Circuit Appellate Opinions

Return to Circuit Opinions

To view Circuit Opinions, select a topic from the dropdown box and click on apply.

Administrative Appeals
Case Case Number Date Filed
Neville D Richards v. Palm Beach County Building And Zoning Code Enforcement119.37 KB 2021CA011366 08/17/2022
Marina v. Seven Kings189.11 KB 2021CA12851 10/19/2022
Hubbard v. PBC Comm on Ethics191.4 KB 2021CA0013108 10/19/2022
A and A Housing v. City of LW Beach121.95 KB 2021CA008111 10/19/2022
Clematis Ventures LLC v. City of West Palm Beach204.05 KB 2021CA013189 12/14/2022
Abandonment of Use (Zoning)
Case Case Number Date Filed
322 South County Rd. v. Town of P.B289.7 KB 2011CA002343 01/13/2012
Annexation of Property
Case Case Number Date Filed
Reed v. Village of Tequesta2.14 MB 2012CA014210 08/01/2013
Architectural Commission
Case Case Number Date Filed
Paul Rampell and Rita Rampell v. Town of Palm Beach173.57 KB 2014CA013648 10/09/2015
Assessment of Fine
Case Case Number Date Filed
Gregory v. City of Atlantis52.89 KB 2008CA039996 10/05/2009
Kevin Easton v. City of Palm Beach Gardens232.12 KB 2015CA014288 10/25/2016
Kevin Easton v. City of Palm Beach Gardens187.05 KB 2015CA014285 10/25/2016
Blue Martini v. City of Boca Raton1.01 MB 2018CA003563 04/16/2019
Code Enforcement
Case Case Number Date Filed
2944 Land Trust v PB PZBA370.53 KB 2021CA1010307 02/23/2023
Competent Substantial Evidence
Case Case Number Date Filed
Jupiter Farms v. Palm Beach County8.83 MB 2008CA017859 03/19/2009
100 Emerald Beach Way v. The Palm Beach Town Council615.3 KB 2017CA010274 08/30/2018
Correction of Order
Case Case Number Date Filed
Bre Sky Bo Holdings v. Town of Lantana52.66 KB 2008CA036244 05/06/2010
Disqualification of Hearing Officer
Case Case Number Date Filed
Barfield v. Town of Jupiter Inlet Colony129.94 KB 2007CA021185 11/01/2008
2600 N Ocean v Boca198.42 KB 2019CA004116 09/16/2020
Equal Employment Board
Case Case Number Date Filed
City of West Palm Beach v. Curtis168.82 KB 2010CA023598 07/01/2011
Findings of Fact by Hearing Officer
Case Case Number Date Filed
Feder v. Palm Beach County184.33 KB 2001CA006044 11/29/2011
Palm Beach Polo v. Village of Wellington1.39 MB 2016CA005700 05/15/2017
M & A Brothers Realty v. Town of Lantana1.54 MB 2018CA009373 06/13/2019
Fines
Case Case Number Date Filed
Byrd Family Trust v. Town of Jupiter529.83 KB 2012CA003213 04/17/2013
Byrd Family Trust v. Town of Jupiter529.83 KB 2012CA006013 04/17/2013
Fourth Amendment Applicability (Administrative searches)
Case Case Number Date Filed
Ettinger v. City of West Palm Beach211.48 KB 2008CA040059 01/29/2010
Jurisdiction
Case Case Number Date Filed
Taylor v. City of Riviera Beach37.03 KB 2013CA016909 12/16/2014
Land Development Regulation/Approval
Case Case Number Date Filed
Village of Wellington v. Jeffrey P. Prudden190.48 KB 2015CA013015 06/30/2016
Waterview Towers v. WPB and Palm Harbor Hotel1.05 MB 2017CA006914 06/08/2018
New Code Violations Raised on Appeal
Case Case Number Date Filed
Royal Poinciana South v. Town of Palm Beach190.97 KB 2008CA016638 04/30/2009
Nuisance
Case Case Number Date Filed
Wellington Residential v. Village of Wellington244.91 KB 2020CA010473 10/01/2021
Ordinances
Case Case Number Date Filed
Esrick v. Village of North Palm Beach975.79 KB 2018CA002517 10/26/2018
Presentation of Evidence
Case Case Number Date Filed
Twin States Marketing v. Palm Beach City6.46 MB 2007AP000131 02/22/2008
Registration Fees
Case Case Number Date Filed
Bradford Electrical v. City of Lake Worth232.64 KB 2007AP000131 02/22/2008
Site Plan Approval
Case Case Number Date Filed
RG Towers LLC v. Town of Lake Park Florida1.12 MB 2016CA005162 03/23/2017
Special Use Permits
Case Case Number Date Filed
Polo West Golf Club, Inc. & Palm Beach Polo, Inc. v. Village of Wellington62.2 KB 2015CA007218 05/31/2016
Standing
Case Case Number Date Filed
1000 Friends of Florida v. Palm Beach County236.52 KB 2008CA15665 02/16/2010
1000 Friends of Florida v. Palm Beach County233.09 KB 2008CA015653 02/16/2010
Neighborhood Alliance of Palm Beach, Inc. Palm Beach Preservation Alliance, LLC, Anne Pepper and William Cooley v. Town of Palm 268.43 KB 2015CA006598 03/03/2016
Status Review Hearing
Case Case Number Date Filed
Equestrian Sport v. Village of Wellington2.56 MB 2012CA0111704 07/15/2013
Timeliness
Case Case Number Date Filed
City of Palm Beach Gardens v. Palm Beach County177.47 KB 2015CA007340 03/18/2016
Traffic Cameras
Case Case Number Date Filed
Ryan v. Town of Juno Beach396.21 KB 2009CA039993 02/02/2011
Kamp v. Town of Juno Beach398.77 KB 2010CA004716 02/02/2011
Gross v. Town of Juno Beach488.28 KB 2009CA026525 02/02/2011
Levin v. Town of Juno Beach, FL659.44 KB 2009CA035334 02/02/2011
University & Colleges
Case Case Number Date Filed
Micah Phillips v. Florida Atlantic University163.01 KB 2015CA007028 02/05/2016
Zoning
Case Case Number Date Filed
Harbour House HOA v. City of Delray Beach23.48 KB 2014CA011943 10/09/2015
Royal Palm Real Estate v. City of Boca Raton365.88 KB 2015CA009676 06/06/2016
Dr. Mohammad Sandhu v. Town of Mangonia Park195.55 KB 2015CA013815 10/25/2016
Flagler WPB v. City of WBP155.98 KB 2020CA000010 05/17/2021
1020 South Ocean v Town of Palm Beach465.46 KB 2022CA001388 07/21/2023
Appeals
Domestic Violence Injunction
Case Case Number Date Filed
Michael Anthony Forman v. State of Florida211.4 KB 2014AP900001 01/21/2015
Orders, Non Final
Case Case Number Date Filed
Affirmative Insurance Co. v. Pauldo8.63 MB 2009CA007739 06/16/2009
Rodrigues v. Unifund CCR Partners67.19 KB 2009AP000033 12/04/2009
Record
Case Case Number Date Filed
Guido v. Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office182.1 KB 2010AP000015 09/01/2011
Carpe v. Airport Parking47.18 KB 2013AP000016 08/28/2013
Lisa Dowd v. All American Asphalt, LLC and George Stevens67.61 KB 2015AP000070 10/25/2016
Kimberly E. Malchuski v. Town of Ocean Ridge1.01 MB 2015AP900003 12/19/2016
Rehearing
Case Case Number Date Filed
State of Florida v. Cohen107.17 KB 2009AP000078 11/18/2010
Subsequent DCA Ruling
Case Case Number Date Filed
DCI MRI, Inc. v. Dairyland Insurance Company41.28 KB 2010CA027097 08/31/2011
Written Opinions
Case Case Number Date Filed
John C. Cassidy Air Conditioning, Inc. v. Fern Evernia Investments, LLC30.44 KB 2008AP000020 11/21/2008
Civil
Arbitration
Case Case Number Date Filed
Abreu v. Vogt4.58 MB 2008CA011314 03/17/2009
Santander Consumer v. Muszynski280.09 KB 2013AP000057 04/29/2014
Spike Von Zamft and Elizabeth Von Zamft v. El Nido Jupiter, LLC235.28 KB 2016AP900007 09/26/2016
Wallace v. Beaulieu-Fawcett202.74 KB 2019AP000104 07/20/2020
Breach of Contract
Case Case Number Date Filed
Craig Jay Perkins v. Howard B. Stevens, Inc.129.14 KB 2014AP000030 01/02/2015
Alba v. Puroclean of North Broward, Inc.836.67 KB 2016AP900283 04/24/2018
Self Discovery Group v Namia1 MB 2017AP000158 02/11/2019
Contempt
Case Case Number Date Filed
Rivernider v. Sterling Villages of Palm Beach Lakes96.79 KB 2009AP000022 03/04/2010
Rivernider v. Sterling Villages of Palm Beach Lakes336.16 KB 2011CA008776 01/09/2013
Conversion/Civil Theft
Case Case Number Date Filed
Why Go to the Dealer Automotive, Inc. v. Westgate & Wabasso, Corp.1.52 MB 2017AP000092 03/12/2018
Damages
Case Case Number Date Filed
Savitz v. Whitney135.96 KB 2012AP000051 02/13/2014
Financial Services Vehicle v. Cabibi1.45 MB 2018AP000004 07/26/2018
Iglesias and Santana v. Weingarten 676.49 KB 2017CC007031 12/11/2018
Default
Case Case Number Date Filed
Bogdanoff v. Broken Sound Club, Inc.122.19 KB 2009AP000056 08/25/2010
Seth Rubeck and Dialysis Services v Ace Amusement Services1.25 MB 2017AP000109 01/14/2019
Dental Negligence
Case Case Number Date Filed
Lane v. Wetherington46.9 KB 2010CA016165 03/26/2011
Deposition
Case Case Number Date Filed
State Farm v. Gun Club Chiropractic28.25 KB 2009CA040160 03/09/2011
Discovery, Privilege
Case Case Number Date Filed
State Farm v. Slossberg190.45 KB 2014CA003304 08/06/2015
Citizens Property Insurance v. One Call Property Services2.01 MB 2017CA003956 01/10/2018
Discovery, Trade Secrets
Case Case Number Date Filed
Collision Concepts, Inc. v. State Farm Insurance Company282 KB 2014CA007531 01/06/2015
State Farm v. Collision Concepts129.83 KB 2014CA007531 02/12/2015
State Farm v. Ortho Florida, LLL78.72 KB 2014CA005260 03/10/2015
State Farm v. Gold Coast Chiropractic Center132.57 KB 2013CA010166 06/09/2015
PB Holding v. Village of Wellington154.51 KB 2014CA008953 06/18/2015
MDM Chiropractic Center v. State Farm61.78 KB 2014CA000769 06/19/2015
Slossberg Family Chiropractic Center v. State Farm69.31 KB 2014CA0000763 06/19/2015
State Farm Fire and Casualty v. Premier Diagnostics Imaging A/A/O Samantha Wasson246.16 KB 2015CA004772 08/02/2015
State Farm v. Slossberg190.45 KB 2014CA003304 08/14/2015
Dismissal
Case Case Number Date Filed
Express Consolidation v. Delray Funding116.26 KB 2007AP000019 10/30/2007
CACV of Colorado v. Wolf71.46 KB 2016AP000067 11/13/2007
Bereaus Investment v. Milian7.67 MB 2008AP000025 03/31/2009
Westport Recovery v. Cordie10.47 MB 2008AP000021 11/20/2009
State National Insurance Co. v. Michael145.58 KB 2009AP000028 10/21/2010
Nantucket v. Palm Beach Florida Hotel1.31 MB 2010AP000003 06/28/2013
Larusso D.C. P.A. of Wellington v. State Farm945.45 KB 2012AP000022 08/29/2013
Progressive American Insurance v. Collision Concepts213.01 KB 2012AP000022 09/28/2015
MDM Chiropractic Center v. Progressive Select Insurance148.45 KB 2014AP000016 04/25/2016
Wolfe v. Nextera Energy, Inc. et al.1.39 MB 2016AP900219 04/02/2017
Mendez v. Araujo722.79 KB 2016AP900286 10/04/2017
Parton v Arana1.27 MB 2018AP000095 05/13/2019