Circuit Appellate Opinions

Return to Circuit Opinions

To view Circuit Opinions, select a topic from the dropdown box and click on apply.

DHSMV
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconHenry v. DHSMV379.71 KB 2021CA004131 02/17/2022
PDF iconRojas v. DHSMV200.39 KB 2021CA005441 02/22/2022
PDF iconRossillo v. DHSMV84.3 KB 2020CA01850 03/04/2022
PDF iconBauman v. DHSMV123.1 KB 2022CA000277 08/17/2022
PDF iconMartin v. DHSMV121.33 KB 2021CA013160 08/17/2022
PDF iconHale v. DHSMV121.07 KB 2021CA013371 12/14/2022
PDF iconHoffman v. DHSMV121.71 KB 2022CA002657 12/14/2022
Affidavits
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconSilvester v. DHSMV50.74 KB 2010CA028962 05/31/2011
PDF iconSchwartz v. DHSMV169.86 KB 2012CA004706 01/01/2012
PDF iconLane v. DHSMV290.13 KB 2012CA007787 12/13/2012
PDF iconTyson v. DHSMV340.06 KB 2012CA010477 01/11/2013
PDF iconBordwell v. DHSMV1002.13 KB 2012CA0084444 07/31/2013
PDF iconMorocco v. DHSMV106.19 KB 2013CA013392 08/01/2016
PDF iconWilson v. DHSMV369.33 KB 2015CA013392 08/01/2016
Alcohol, Evidence of
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconEric Bahien v. State of Florida, DHSMV121.41 KB 2015CA009311 08/08/2016
Blood Test
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconDoran v. DHSMV78.55 KB 2011CA007061 08/30/2011
PDF iconGracia v. State of Florida213.61 KB 2012AP900041 05/08/2014
PDF iconMejia v. DHSMV1.22 MB 2017CA004541 11/28/2017
PDF iconDavis v. DHSMV2.13 MB 2017CA011092 08/15/2018
PDF iconSmiley v. DHSMV177.93 KB 2019CA008960 12/20/2019
PDF iconNewcombe v. DHSMV207.37 KB 2020CA001875 09/01/2020
Breath Sample
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconCounts v. DHSMV182.59 KB 2011CA019524 09/05/2012
PDF iconRosa Elena Papper v. DHSMV217.08 KB 2014CA006122 02/28/2016
PDF iconKorpeck v. DHSMV620.99 KB 2017CA005668 11/14/2017
Constitutional Challenges
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconCaban v. DHSMV605.85 KB 2016AP900020 03/02/2017
Control of Vehicle
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconSarmiento v. DHSMV22.22 KB 2007CA016857 02/14/2008
Disqualification
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconLetron T. Kelly v. State of Florida1000.63 KB 2016CA006844 02/01/2017
Driving Record as Competent Substantial Evidence
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconMeccariello v. DHSMV133.8 KB 2010CA014372 08/24/2010
Evidence in Conflict
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconMitchell v. DHSMV1.11 MB 2017CA001438 09/15/2017
Hardship License
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconManno v. DHSMV32.4 KB 2013CA013530 02/06/2014
PDF iconRooney v. DHSMV35.7 KB 2013CA011439 02/18/2014
PDF iconStevens v. DHSMV41.58 KB 2014CA002305 11/24/2014
PDF iconDore v. DHSMV79.2 KB 2020CA004285 09/30/2020
Hearing Officer, Neutral Detached
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconShortreed v. DHSMV271.13 KB 2008CA033076 09/24/2009
Implied Consent Law - Applicability
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconStachura v. DHSMV217.65 KB 2011CA004239 08/25/2011
Incapacity
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconNelson v. DHSMV178.71 KB 2009CA013822 10/05/2009
Initial Traffic Stop - Lawfulness
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconDorn v. DHSMV725.63 KB 2013CA003593 08/02/2013
PDF iconDeluce v. DHSMV427.83 KB 2014CA010131 02/26/2015
PDF iconGibson v. DHSMV172.36 KB 2015CA014330 08/17/2016
PDF iconFranklin v. DHSMV1.07 MB 2016CA007775 06/08/2017
PDF iconWade v. DHSMV2.39 MB 2018CA000714 07/06/2018
PDF iconQuinn v. DHSMV255.48 KB 2020CA002888 11/06/2020
Law Enforcement Training Certificate
Case Case Number Date Filed
Fagu V. DHSMV (withdrawn) 2013CA011968 10/07/2013
PDF iconFagu V. DHSMV293.64 KB 2013CA11968 06/24/2014
PDF iconGordon v. DHSMV294.98 KB 2013CA011969 06/24/2014
PDF iconChiavetta v. DHSMV292.28 KB 2013CA011967 06/24/2014
PDF iconHernandez v. DHSMV287.57 KB 2013CA011966 06/24/2014
Length of Suspension
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconRandolph v. DHSMV36.52 KB 2008CA033372 11/03/2009
PDF iconKanter v. DHSMV69.29 KB 2011CA008363 01/30/2012
Notice
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconTucker v. DHSMV301.34 KB 2013CA001846 05/06/2013
Permits
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconBoivin v. DHSMV (Overruled Moya v. DHSMV)294.23 KB 2011CA017422 09/05/2012
PDF iconRivera v. DHSMV (Overruled Moya v. DHSMV)348.56 KB 2011CA017424 09/05/2012
PDF iconWalker v. DHSMV (Overruled Moya v. DHSMV)129.99 KB 2012CA010478 04/04/2013
PDF iconPasa v. DHSMV (Overruled Moya v. DHSMV)93.13 KB 2013CA004621 04/16/2013
PDF iconMoya v. DHSMV242.04 KB 2013CA011295 06/17/2014
PDF iconMannelly v. DHSMV269.57 KB 2013CA00911 06/17/2014
Procedure
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconCordaro v. DHSMV200.6 KB 2019CA015583 04/21/2021
PDF iconMastroleo v. DHSMV153.91 KB 2020CA006391 05/14/2021
PDF iconMorganstein v. DHSMV125.81 KB 2020CA000464 05/17/2021
Refusal Incident Lawful Arrest
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconMaesel v. DHSMV98.06 KB 2011CA002344 09/26/2011
PDF iconElhilow v. DHSMV56.74 KB 2010CA001053 11/14/2011
PDF iconFlanagan v. DHSMV57.16 KB 2011CA008415 11/14/2011
PDF iconFraxedas v. DHSMV56.08 KB 2010CA027150 11/14/2011
PDF iconMarsh v. DHSMV56.79 KB 201CA018240 11/14/2011
PDF iconThomas v. DHSMV56.1 KB 2010CA020569 11/14/2011
PDF iconMahoney v. DHSMV149.22 KB 2010CA006254 02/03/2012
PDF iconLynch v. DHSMV156.33 KB 2011CA000834 02/03/2012
PDF iconPace v. DHSMV57.55 KB 2010CA022624 05/09/2012
PDF iconSmith v. DHSMV56.72 KB 2010CA030268 05/09/2012
PDF iconJackson v. DHSMV75.43 KB 2009CA025928 12/21/2012
PDF iconBeal v. DHSMV69.33 KB 2011CA003973 12/21/2012
PDF iconScott v. DHSMV67.3 KB 2011CA004711 12/21/2012
PDF iconRabarozzi v. DHSMV63.34 KB 2010CA022733 12/21/2012
PDF iconSavnik v. DHSMV1.14 MB 2016CA01220 06/01/2017
Revocation of License
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconRevocation of License202.84 KB 2014CA004759 11/24/2014
Rule Making Authority
Case Case Number Date Filed
Davis v. DHSMV 2008CA001590 07/17/2009
Scrivener's Error
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconFasel v. DHSMV64.55 KB 2012CA018527 08/01/2013
PDF iconFloyd v. DHSMV53.65 KB 2009CA004015 09/09/2013
PDF iconSipp v. DHSMV189.9 KB 2019CA011048 04/23/2020
Subpoena
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconJohnson v DHSMV8.47 MB 2008CA023871 03/19/2009
PDF iconSexton v. DHSMV5.91 MB 2008CA028357 06/04/2009
PDF iconDe Jong v. DHSMV44.33 KB 2009CA006551 11/19/2009
PDF iconDemerac v. DHSMV45.97 KB 2008CA034494 01/20/2010
PDF iconReynolds v. DHSMV65.84 KB 2009CA020777 03/09/2010
PDF iconKirby v. DHSMV30.11 KB 2009CA007794 03/23/2010
PDF iconHertel v. DHSMV32.06 KB 2010CA001531 06/09/2010
PDF iconFoster v. DHSMV39.01 KB 2012CA000069 08/01/2012
Underage Drinking
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconElder v. DHSMV215.43 KB 2009CA038373 04/13/2011
Urine Sample
Case Case Number Date Filed
PDF iconBrass v. DHSMV283.42 KB 2011CA005919 10/05/2011
PDF iconPaymar v. DHSMV202.5 KB 2018CA12978 01/23/2020