Circuit Appellate Opinions

Return to Circuit Opinions

To view Circuit Opinions, select a topic from the dropdown box and click on apply.

DHSMV
Refusal Incident Lawful Arrest
Case Case Number Date Filed
Fraxedas v. DHSMV56.08 KB 2010CA027150 11/14/2011
Elhilow v. DHSMV56.74 KB 2010CA001053 11/14/2011
Thomas v. DHSMV56.1 KB 2010CA020569 11/14/2011
Marsh v. DHSMV56.79 KB 201CA018240 11/14/2011
Flanagan v. DHSMV57.16 KB 2011CA008415 11/14/2011
Lynch v. DHSMV156.33 KB 2011CA000834 02/03/2012
Mahoney v. DHSMV149.22 KB 2010CA006254 02/03/2012
Smith v. DHSMV56.72 KB 2010CA030268 05/09/2012
Pace v. DHSMV57.55 KB 2010CA022624 05/09/2012
Scott v. DHSMV67.3 KB 2011CA004711 12/21/2012
Rabarozzi v. DHSMV63.34 KB 2010CA022733 12/21/2012
Jackson v. DHSMV75.43 KB 2009CA025928 12/21/2012
Beal v. DHSMV69.33 KB 2011CA003973 12/21/2012
Savnik v. DHSMV1.14 MB 2016CA01220 06/01/2017
Revocation of License
Case Case Number Date Filed
Revocation of License202.84 KB 2014CA004759 11/24/2014
Rule Making Authority
Case Case Number Date Filed
Davis v. DHSMV 2008CA001590 07/17/2009
Scrivener's Error
Case Case Number Date Filed
Fasel v. DHSMV64.55 KB 2012CA018527 08/01/2013
Floyd v. DHSMV53.65 KB 2009CA004015 09/09/2013
Sipp v. DHSMV189.9 KB 2019CA011048 04/23/2020
Subpoena
Case Case Number Date Filed
Johnson v DHSMV8.47 MB 2008CA023871 03/19/2009
Sexton v. DHSMV5.91 MB 2008CA028357 06/04/2009
De Jong v. DHSMV44.33 KB 2009CA006551 11/19/2009
Demerac v. DHSMV45.97 KB 2008CA034494 01/20/2010
Reynolds v. DHSMV65.84 KB 2009CA020777 03/09/2010
Kirby v. DHSMV30.11 KB 2009CA007794 03/23/2010
Hertel v. DHSMV32.06 KB 2010CA001531 06/09/2010
Foster v. DHSMV39.01 KB 2012CA000069 08/01/2012
Underage Drinking
Case Case Number Date Filed
Elder v. DHSMV215.43 KB 2009CA038373 04/13/2011
Urine Sample
Case Case Number Date Filed
Brass v. DHSMV283.42 KB 2011CA005919 10/05/2011
Paymar v. DHSMV202.5 KB 2018CA12978 01/23/2020
Disqualification
Attorney
Case Case Number Date Filed
Rose, Altomare and Altomare v. Addison Gallery, Inc.29.55 KB 2007AP000106 09/26/2007
Hearing Officer/Magistrate
Case Case Number Date Filed
McFarlane v. State of Florida1.27 MB 2017CA003184 08/02/2017
Hearing Officer/Special Magistrate
Case Case Number Date Filed
Barfield v. Town of Jupiter129.94 KB 2007CA021185 11/21/2008
Judge
Case Case Number Date Filed
Carrier v. State of Florida390.99 KB 06-04AC A02 02/10/2005
Carrier v State of Florida369.81 KB 06-04AC A02 02/10/2006
Gibson v. Klingensmith 2008AP000057 02/24/2009
Credit Corp. Solutions v. Samina Chowdhury1.55 MB 2018CA001216 05/10/2018
Hearsay
Hearsay
Case Case Number Date Filed
Harp v. State of Florida149.05 KB 2011AP900047 09/03/2014
Kelly Monique Mays v. State of Florida93.13 KB 2014AP900004 01/13/2015
Van Kelson v. State of Florida195.74 KB 2018AP000027 06/12/2020
Jurisdiction
Jurisdictional Limits
Case Case Number Date Filed
Magro v. White54.34 KB 2009AP000051 11/23/2010
Personal Jurisdiction
Case Case Number Date Filed
The Publiese Co. v. Beaux-Artes, LTD32.4 KB 2006AP000050 05/25/2007
Preemption
Case Case Number Date Filed
Arzoumanian v. Ford Motor Credit Co. LLC71.19 KB 2015AP000085 08/02/2016
Venue
Case Case Number Date Filed
Willis v. Webster64.62 KB 2008AP000018 09/16/2009
Amlong and Amlong v. Semo128.72 KB 2014AP000069 11/09/2015
Pension Funds
Pension Funds
Case Case Number Date Filed
Epstein v. Boynton Beach PD Officers Pension Fund249.72 KB 2013CA018598 10/20/2014
Personal Injury Protection
Affidavit
Case Case Number Date Filed
DiBlasio v. Progressive187.74 KB 2006AP000001 08/13/2007
Progressive v. DiBlasio73.79 KB 2006AP000041, 2006AP000058 01/24/2008
United Auto Ins. v. Abacoa Town Center75.52 KB 2008AP000044 10/05/2009
Attorney's Fees
Case Case Number Date Filed
Progressive v. DiBlasio30.83 KB 2006AP000045 10/31/2007
Beaches of MRI v. State Farm (withdrawn) 2015AP000039 02/13/2017
Beaches of MRI v. State Farm1.71 MB 2015AP000039 05/25/2017
Collateral Source Payment
Case Case Number Date Filed
Central PB Physician and Urgent Care v. State Farm1016.61 KB 2017AP000041 03/25/2019
CPT Codes
Case Case Number Date Filed
DiBlasio v. Progressive187.74 KB 2006AP000001 08/13/2007
Progressive v. DiBlasio73.79 KB 2006AP000041, 2006AP000058 01/24/2008
Declaratory Judgment
Case Case Number Date Filed
Progressive Select Ins. Co. v. Wade1.85 MB 2016AP900269 08/21/2018
Demand Letter
Case Case Number Date Filed
Fountain Imaging v. Progressive144.22 KB 2006AP000025 03/30/2007
Precision Diagnostics v. State Farm Mutual2.25 MB 2006AP000001 08/13/2007
A Kaufman Chiropractic v. Progressive105.65 KB 2008AP000032 08/20/2009
State Farm Fire v. MRI Associates173.9 KB 2009AP000014 05/04/2010
Lake Worth Emergency Chiropractic Center v. State Farm Mutual98.39 KB 2012AP000034 07/14/2016
Precision Diagnostics v. State Farm Mutual (withdrawn) 2014AP000018 02/07/2017
Progressive v. Wade (withdrawn) 2016AP900269 07/03/2018
Disclosure and Acknowledgment Form
Case Case Number Date Filed
Jane Bistline, MD v. USAA Casualty109.1 KB 2009AP000019 06/02/2010
St. Lucie Injury Center v. USAA Casualty68.76 KB 2009AP000040 02/28/2011
Examination Under Oath
Case Case Number Date Filed
Millennium Rehabilitation v. Mercury Insurance29.24 KB 2012AP900056 08/28/2013
Exhaustion of Benefits
Case Case Number Date Filed
Progressive v. DiBlasio153.52 KB 2006AP000009 03/23/2007
Expert Witness
Case Case Number Date Filed
Volmy v. Progressive78.78 KB 2005AP000074 05/23/2007
Notice to Produce
Case Case Number Date Filed
Mercury Ins. Co. v. Med Manage Group158.78 KB 2009AP000016 04/08/2010
Payment Schedule
Case Case Number Date Filed
Kehrig v. Mercury Insurance Co. of Florida263.65 KB 2012AP000060 05/30/2014
Progressive Select v. Injury Treatment Center1.58 MB 2016AP900186 05/08/2017
Reimbursement of Benefits
Case Case Number Date Filed
Continental Casualty v. State Farm Fire and Casualty227.36 KB 2010AP000043 08/09/2011
Summary Judgment
Case Case Number Date Filed
Ocean Chiropractic and Health Center, Inc. v. First Floridian Auto and Home Insurance Company1.24 MB 2017AP000120 08/17/2018
Work Product
Case Case Number Date Filed
State Farm v. Premier Diagnostic Imaging Clauvel Benjamin134.38 KB 2014CA004977 08/28/2015
Small Claims
Pretrial Conference
Case Case Number Date Filed
Capital One Bank v. Melton30.19 KB 2007AP000162 04/15/2008
Palm Beach Atlantic Univ. v. Campbell67.27 KB 2008AP000041 09/16/2009
Set-Off
Case Case Number Date Filed
Kutchulis v. JCJB Enterprises, Inc.113.15 KB 2012AP000053 05/06/2013
Summary Disposition
Case Case Number Date Filed
Randolph Williams v. City Towing, LLC2.53 MB 2015AP000078 12/14/2016
Traffic
Case Case Number Date Filed
Brian Hobby Barnes v Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles411.56 KB 2018CA000493 08/21/2019
Yoakum, Timothy C. v. City of Boynton Beach186.07 KB 2021AP000009 02/15/2023
Souffrant, Tarheayis Rony v. State of Florida185.6 KB 2022AP000001 02/15/2023
Charging Document
Case Case Number Date Filed
Verhoeven v. State of Florida974.86 KB 2017AP000058 03/01/2018
Elements Required
Case Case Number Date Filed
Young v. State of Florida616 KB 2016TR146343 01/18/2018
Red Light Camera
Case Case Number Date Filed
Acosta v. Palm Beach Sheriff's Office122.88 KB 2013AP900039 09/22/2014
Carl A. Cascio v. City of Boynton Beach205.63 KB 2013AP900064 06/30/2016
City of Boyton Beach v. Lendon Eugene Boss3.08 MB 2015AP000053 09/30/2016
State/County Road
Case Case Number Date Filed
Evelyn Pezzo v. Palm Beach Sheriff's Office53.57 KB 2014AP900029 12/10/2015
Suspension of Driver's License
Case Case Number Date Filed
Geoffrey Jean Louis v. Palm Beach Sheriff's Office127.77 KB 2015AP000057 05/04/2016
Trial
Blood Draw Supression
Case Case Number Date Filed
Houston v. State113.36 KB 2011AP900033 10/23/2012
Closing Argument
Case Case Number Date Filed
Elmizadeh v. State293.42 KB 2007AP900038 06/27/2007
Davis v. State62.5 KB 2009AP900090 08/05/2010
Hearsay
Case Case Number Date Filed
Gonzalez v. State57.68 KB 2013AP900032 04/25/2013
Joint & Several
Case Case Number Date Filed
Herb & Kauffman v. Reflections of Boca18.54 KB 2009AP000066 10/18/2010
Philip Heller, PA v. Reflections of Boca18.06 KB 2009AP000071 10/18/2010
Sunshine Wireless v. Reflections of Boca96.08 KB 2009AP000070 10/18/2010
Jury Instructions
Case Case Number Date Filed
El-Maayergy v. State of Florida26.74 KB 2007AP900035 02/07/2008
Welsh v. State of Florida83.86 KB 2007AP900045 03/27/2008
Sims v. State of Florida69.66 KB 2010AP900059 12/12/2011
Murray v. State of Florida163.58 KB 2012AP900035 04/22/2013
Brown v. State of Florida65.24 KB 2013AP900032 11/04/2014